Forty Defendants Charged in Separate Schemes that Resulted in Thousands of Identities Stolen and Millions of Dollars in Identity Theft Tax Filings
|U.S. Attorney’s Office October 10, 2012|
MIAMI—Federal charges were filed today against 40 defendants in 20 separate cases, dealing with thousands of stolen identities and millions of dollars of fraudulent identity theft tax filings. Today’s cases reaffirm the joint federal and local commitment to crack-down on stolen identity tax refund (SITR) fraud perpetrators.
The charges were announced by Wifredo A. Ferrer, U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Florida; Richard Weber, Chief, Internal Revenue Service-Criminal Investigation Division (IRS-CI); Paula Reid, Special Agent in Charge, U.S. Secret Service (USSS); Michael B. Steinbach, Acting Special Agent in Charge, FBI, Miami Field Office; Antonio J. Gomez, Acting Inspector in Charge; U.S. Postal Inspection Service (USPS), Miami Division; Guy Fallen, Special Agent in Charge, Social Security Administration, Office of Inspector General (SSA-OIG); Kelly R. Jackson, Special Agent in Charge, IRS-CI, St. Paul Field Office; Steven Steinberg, Chief, Aventura, Fla., Police Department; Larry Gomer, Interim Chief, North Miami Beach Police Department; and Juan Santana, Chief, Miami-Dade Police Department.
According to the Federal Trade Commission, Florida had the highest rate of identity theft in the United States in 2011. While identity theft in Florida ranks highest in the United States, the identity theft rate in Miami has reached near epidemic proportions. Florida’s rate of 178 complaints per 100,000 residents—the highest in the United States—is dwarfed by the Miami rate of 324.1 complaints per 100,000 residents.
Moreover, a September 2012 report by the U.S. Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) determined that Florida has the highest rate of stolen identity tax refund fraud in the United States. The report identified 74,496 potentially fraudulent returns filed in Miami resulting in more than $280 million in bogus refunds. Miami’s per capita number of false returns based on identity theft was 46 times the national average, and its per capita SITR fraud dollar value was more than 70 times the national average. This problem is projected to grow: the TIGTA report estimates that the IRS could issue as much as $21 billion in fraudulent tax refunds over the next five years.
In an attempt to combat the rising wave of stolen identity refund scams, and armed with newly enhanced investigative and prosecutorial tools under the Department of Justice’s Tax Directive 144, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Florida established the South Florida Identity Theft Tax Fraud Strike Force. The members of the strike force include IRS-CI, U.S. Secret Service, FBI, USPS, City of Aventura Police Department, Miami-Dade Police Department, North Miami Beach Police Department and the SSA-OIG. The focus of the strike force is to investigate and prosecute SITR fraud in the Southern District of Florida. Today, U.S. Attorney Ferrer, joined by members of the Identity Theft Tax Fraud Strike Force, announced the most recent results of their investigative efforts.
U.S. Attorney Ferrer said, “So far this year, we have charged a total of 79 individuals responsible for almost $40 million in fraudulent tax refunds obtained through identity theft. The cases being investigated and prosecuted include victims from all walks of life, including police officers, potential U.S. Marine recruits, members of the Armed Forces, holocaust survivors, school children, hospital patients, the elderly and infirm, incarcerated prisoners, and even the dead. In addition, our cases show a troubling change in the nature of these cases, away from traditional white collar criminals to more violent criminals, like gang members and narco-traffickers, who are using stolen identity refund scams to fuel their other, violent, criminal activities. We will continue to crack down on identity thieves who are lining their pockets with our tax dollars and using violence to obtain the personal identification information of others.”
“Today’s announcement should reassure American taxpayers that IRS Criminal Investigation has put into action our pledge to make investigating identify theft and refund fraud a top priority,” said IRS-CI Chief Weber. “Be assured that we are serious about investigating these crimes and, as we capitalize on the collective strength of the Identity Theft Tax Fraud Strike Force, we will succeed in vigorously pursuing the criminals who steal from the American taxpayer.”
“The U.S. Secret Service is glad to be an integral part of the Strike Force coordinated between the U.S. Attorney’s Office and the Internal Revenue Service to combat this fraud scheme that is plaguing South Florida,” said USSS Special Agent in Charge Reid.
“Identity theft tax fraud has reached an epidemic level and these cases demonstrate that the FBI and its law enforcement partners will devote considerable resources to address the issue,” said FBI Acting Special Agent in Charge Steinbach. “Prevention by way of educating the public is also key to reducing the amount of this type fraud. Consequently, we urge the public to visit www.ftc.gov or www.ic3.gov, as it provides detailed information on how to help deter, detect, and defend against identity theft.”
Acting Inspector in Charge of the Miami Division of the USPS Gomez said, “As a member of the Identity Theft Tax Fraud Strike Force, the U.S. Postal Inspection Service will work diligently with the U.S. Attorney’s Office and with law enforcement at the federal, state and local level to protect American citizens from suspects who prey on their identification for financial gain. Our commitment to the South Florida community is to continue to pursue these cases under Mr. Ferrer’s leadership and guidance so that the U.S. Mails are never used as a conduit to defraud unknowing victims of this type of crime.”
Special Agent in Charge of the SSA-OIG Fallen said, “Assuming the identity of another to commit fraud, unfortunately, is a common occurrence. SSA-OIG special agents are well-trained to detect, investigate, and locate identity thieves, and SSA/OIG, in concert with the U.S. Attorney’s Office, will investigate and prosecute those who commit identity theft and defraud Social Security trust funds.”
“It is through the collaborative efforts of our agencies that we have been successful in investigating and prosecuting tax fraud in Miami-Dade County. We are pleased with the outcome and will continue to work together with our partner agencies in order to make positive impacts on our community,” said Miami-Dade Police Department Chief Santana.
An indictment is only an accusation, and a defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.
The cases announced today include:
- United States v. Serge St-Vil, et al., Case No. 12-20768-CR-Scola
- United States v. Rodney Saint Fleur, Case No. 12-20772-CR-Scola
- United States v. Lineten Belizaire, et al., Case No. 12-20763-CR-Altonaga
- United States v. Frantz Pierre, et al., Case No. 12-20696-CR-Cooke
- United States v. Jean Noel, et al., Case No. 12-20740-CR-Dimitrouleas
- United States v. Douglas Michael Young, et al., Case No. 12-20767-CR-Dimitrouleas
- United States v. Bridgette Piedra and Jane Piedra, Case No. 12-20761-CR-Ungaro
- United States v. Rose Mary Steed and Demetrice Nicole Steed, Case No. 12-20773-CR-Huck
- United States v. Michael Wilson, Case No.12- 60253-CR-Cohn
- United States v. Johnny Alexander Melo, Case No. 12-20762-CR-Graham
- United States v. Arthy Icart and Charlton Escarmant, Case No. 12-20764-CR-Lenard
- United States v. Michlson LaRochelle, Case No. 12-14074-CR-Graham
- United States v. Alexander Louis, Case No. 12-60250-CR-Williams
- United States v. Vildeon Sajouse, Case No. 12-3364-MJ-Palermo
- United States v. Frantz Auguste, Case No. 12-3363-MJ-Palermo
- United States v. Cesar Coureaux, Case No. 12-20708-CR-Altonaga
- United States v. Math Benjamin, Case No. 12-20707-CR-Cooke
- United States v. Thierry Audren, Case No. 12-20738-CR-Williams
- United States v. Natoya Mashea Handy, Case No. 12-20771-CR-Rosenbaum
- United States v. Luis Enrique Ledee Bernard a/k/a Luis L. Bernard, Case No. 12-20776- CR-Moreno